Last updated October 9, 2026 · ranked from 952 Google reviews · How we rank
This list ranks 5 thrift stores in and around Holland, MI, led by Legacy Thrift, Community Action House Resale South and Gateway Mission Store. Together they have 952 Google reviews; Legacy Thrift has the highest Google rating on the list at 4.4. Every place on the list is in Holland, MI. Rankings weigh Google rating, review volume, how complete and current each listing is, and our own notes on each place.
Cleanliness, usable secondhand goods, and practical shopping amenities earn Legacy Thrift the No. 1 spot in Holland, MI. At 813 Lincoln Ave, the store holds a 4.4 Google rating from 129 reviews. Positive reviewers describe a clean interior, nice items, and helpful staff, with one noting a substantial store refresh. Price feedback is mixed: one reviewer found prices decent, while another compared them unfavorably with new retail. Free parking, a wheelchair-accessible entrance, and Monday-through-Saturday hours make visits straightforward.
Tested electronics and inspected, repaired bikes help Community Action House Resale South earn the No. 2 spot in Holland, MI. Its selection spans clothing, furniture, toys, vintage items, and decor, with purchases supporting Community Action House’s work to end poverty and help families prosper. Electronics include a 48-hour return policy, and furniture delivery starts at $40. Reviewers praise the clean, organized store and varied selection, though one notes tight aisles and higher prices than some alternatives. The store holds a 4.3 Google rating from 142 reviews.
Tested electronics
Inspected and repaired bikes
Furniture delivery available
“Great prices and good selection of resale items. Staff is ultra friendly and store and bathrooms are very clean. Highly recommend!”
Work at Community Action House Resale South? Get your badge
Checked jigsaw puzzles give Gateway Mission Store a specific reason to take the No. 3 spot among thrift stores in Holland, MI: one reviewer says puzzles are assembled before sale and boxes marked complete or with the number of missing pieces. Another praises the prices, cleanliness, and organization. The 26,000-square-foot store and donation center holds a 4.3 Google rating from 351 reviews. Operated by Gateway Mission, it also provides career and educational opportunities for participants in its nine-month work training and recovery program.
Checked jigsaw puzzles
Clothing recycling
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
“This resale store is located in Holland Mich., Best ever! Jigsaw PUZZLES? They actually have a group of people outside the store that will put together the puzzles and mark the box complete or how many pieces missing before selling them…”
A dress selection praised for its range of sizes and styles helps Goodwill Store and Donation Center earn rank 4 in Holland, MI. At 1024 Washington Ave, this nonprofit-chain store carries pre-owned clothing, furniture, and housewares, with one reviewer also highlighting jewelry near the front counter. Its 4.2-star Google rating across 133 reviews supports the pick, though pricing draws mixed feedback. Daily hours, a donation center, and clothing recycling add practical reasons to stop, whether you’re browsing or clearing out a closet.
Wide dress selection
Clothing recycling
Open daily
“Great prices on some stuff some stuff overpriced but great friendly staff”
Work at Goodwill Store and Donation Center? Get your badge
Furniture and appliances are the draw at Estate Sales Warehouse, which earns rank 5 for its estate-liquidation focus and daily-changing inventory. At 753 Lincoln Ave in Holland, MI, the large resale store mixes used goods with brand-new furniture and new scratch-and-dent appliances. Reviewers highlight the furniture selection, including recliners, though opinions on prices differ. Its 4.1 Google rating from 197 reviews, seven-day schedule, and options for delivery and in-store pickup round out the reasons to visit.
Daily inventory changes
Furniture and appliances
Delivery available
“Lots of recliners and other furniture and some appliances. The prices seemed high for used furniture. Like I would rather spend a little bit more and get something new.”
Ratings and review counts shown are Google ratings, displayed with attribution.
How we ranked this list
Each thrift store is scored on a Bayesian-weighted rating (its rating adjusted for how many reviews it has compared with the Holland category average), how recently we verified its details, and how complete its listing is. Scores and ranks are stored, so the order only changes when the underlying data changes.
Which thrift stores in Holland, MI are open on Sunday?
Goodwill Store and Donation Center at 1024 Washington Ave opens Sunday from 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. Estate Sales Warehouse at 753 Lincoln Ave opens noon to 6 p.m. Gateway Mission Store, Community Action House Resale South, Legacy Thrift, Ditto Upscale Resale, and Mommy 'N Me Resale LLC are closed Sundays.
Where can I shop for secondhand furniture and arrange delivery in Holland, MI?
Estate Sales Warehouse specializes in furniture and appliances and offers delivery and in-store pickup. Community Action House Resale South at 694 Michigan Ave carries furniture and offers furniture delivery starting at $40. Legacy Thrift also lists delivery as an available service.
Where can I buy or consign children’s clothing in Holland, MI?
Mommy 'N Me Resale LLC at 579 E 8th St carries children’s clothing from preemie through sizes 14/16, plus maternity clothing, baby gear, toys, and books. You can bring items to consign or sell without an appointment during business hours: 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Saturday.
Which store tests used electronics and checks bikes before selling them?
Community Action House Resale South thoroughly tests all electronics and provides a 48-hour return policy for them. Every bike is inspected and repaired before reaching the sales floor. The store opens 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Saturday at 694 Michigan Ave, Holland, MI.
Where can I donate secondhand goods in Holland, MI?
Gateway Mission Store and Goodwill Store and Donation Center both operate donation centers. Community Action House Resale South offers free donation pickup and a covered canopy for drop-offs. Gateway Mission Store, Goodwill, and Ditto Upscale Resale also list clothing recycling among their services.
1
